Testosterone Replacement Therapy: Myths, Misinformation, and Mistakes
Testosterone Replacement Therapy (TRT) has become a hot topic on the internet—especially as more men seek answers for fatigue, brain fog, low libido, and loss of strength. Unfortunately, with the surge in popularity has come a flood of misinformation. Social-media “experts” and online forums often spread myths that cause confusion and— in some cases—fear around what testosterone therapy really is and how it works.
For men genuinely struggling with low testosterone, this misinformation can be confusing and even dangerous. Let’s clear the air about what TRT really is, who it’s for, and some of the biggest mistakes men are making when trying to manage it on their own.
What Testosterone Replacement Therapy Really Is
TRT is a medically supervised treatment designed to restore testosterone levels in men who have clinically low levels—confirmed by lab testing—and accompanied by symptoms.¹
Common symptoms of low testosterone include:
Low libido or erectile dysfunction
Fatigue or loss of motivation
Decreased muscle mass or strength
Weight gain, especially around the mid-section
Brain fog or irritability
Loss of morning erections
A proper TRT program involves comprehensive lab work, individualized dosing, and ongoing monitoring by a licensed healthcare provider. This ensures hormones remain within physiologic ranges and potential side-effects are caught early.²
Common Mistakes Men Are Making with TRT
Unfortunately, many men are seeking solutions online—through “coaches,” underground suppliers, or other unregulated sources. Here’s why that’s a bad idea:
No medical oversight. Without labs and follow-up, you have no idea what your hormone levels actually are, or how your body is responding.
Fake or contaminated products. Studies show black-market testosterone often contains no active hormone, the wrong hormone, or dangerous contaminants.³
Incorrect dosing. Too much, or too little, leads to unpredictable results and potentially serious side-effects.
No accountability. If something goes wrong—an infection, blood clot, or liver injury—there’s no one responsible or qualified to help.
Remember: testosterone therapy is a medical treatment, not a fitness supplement. It should always be managed by a licensed provider who understands endocrine health and knows how to monitor for long-term safety.⁴
Even men who have a legitimate prescription can make avoidable mistakes. Here are a few of the most common.
1. Skipping Labs or Follow-Up Visits
Ongoing monitoring is essential. It means checking total and free testosterone, estradiol, hematocrit, lipid levels, liver enzymes, and free/total PSA .⁵
Skipping these checks may lead to imbalances and complications like thickened blood (elevated hematocrit) or estrogen-related side-effects that could have been managed early.
2. Ignoring Lifestyle Factors
TRT does not replace healthy habits. Lack of sleep, poor diet, high stress, and excessive alcohol all suppress testosterone—even if you’re on therapy. Addressing these root factors helps your therapy work better and may even reduce your need for medication over time.
3. Not Managing Estrogen Levels Properly
Your body converts some testosterone into estrogen— a process that’s natural and necessary. Too much suppression of estrogen can lead to joint pain, low mood, or sexual dysfunction. The goal is not elimination of estrogen; estrogen can, at a balanced level, be protective for the heart and brain. On the other-hand, too much estrogen conversion can also lead to mood changes, mid-abdominal weight gain, and breast tissue growth. Finding the right balance requires a trained provider who can navigate the line.
4. Expecting Instant Results
TRT isn’t an instant ticket to a shredded physique. It can support lean muscle growth when combined with consistent strength training, good nutrition, and recovery—but it is not magic. What TRT really offers is improved energy, better recovery, and more motivation to sustain a healthy lifestyle.³ It can take several weeks to notice improvements; energy, mood, and libido typically improve first, while body composition and strength take longer.
5. Trusting Social Media Over Science
It’s tempting to follow advice from fitness influencers or Reddit threads, but hormones and humans are complex. What worked for one man may not apply to another. Dosing, frequency, and lab targets must always be individualized. Here are some common myths floating around in both the “pro-TRT” and “against-TRT” camps online:
Myth #1: “Testosterone therapy will make you infertile forever.”
It is true that TRT can temporarily suppress sperm production, since your body may reduce its own testosterone output when it senses an external source.⁷ ⁸ But this is not necessarily permanent. With proper management—and when fertility is a goal—there are ways to support sperm production during or after TRT using treatments like hCG or clomiphene under a clinician’s guidance.⁶
Myth #2: “Once you start TRT, you can never stop.”
Not true in all cases. While some men with true hypogonadism may need long-term treatment, others may recover natural production if low testosterone was caused by reversible factors (stress, poor sleep, certain medications, obesity). Addressing those root causes may help restore production—but discontinuation must always be done under supervision.⁹
Myth #3: “More testosterone is better.”
This is one of the most dangerous misconceptions online. Optimal testosterone means balanced testosterone—not excessively high levels. Over-supplementing can lead to acne, mood swings, elevated red blood-cell counts (hematocrit), and cardiovascular strain.¹⁰ Higher is not better—just riskier.⁶
The Bottom Line
Testosterone replacement therapy can be life-changing for the right patient—when done correctly. It is not a shortcut or a “hack.” It is a legitimate medical treatment that requires careful diagnosis, ongoing monitoring, and respect for your body’s natural systems.
If you suspect low testosterone, begin with a comprehensive evaluation: symptoms, sleep, stress, lifestyle factors, and appropriate labs. Do not guess. Do not self-medicate. Definitely do not order black-market products online.
With the right guidance, TRT can help you feel like yourself again—stronger, more focused, more confident.
Book a FREE Care Call Today
to explore how we can help you feel your best.
Active Patient? Schedule your follow-up today and reconnect with your Superior provider for personalized guidance.
Disclaimer: The content provided on this website is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The information presented does not constitute medical recommendations and should not be used to guide clinical decisions. Always seek the advice of a licensed healthcare provider regarding any medical condition or treatment. Do not disregard or delay professional medical care based on information found on this site. Some services may involve compounded medications that have not been reviewed by the FDA for safety or effectiveness; no therapeutic claims are made for these products. Visuals are for illustrative purposes only; individuals shown are not actual patients. Individual results may vary.
References
Bhasin S, Brito JP, Cunningham GR, et al. Testosterone Therapy in Men With Hypogonadism. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2018;103(5):1715-1744. (Endocrine Society)
Jayasena CN, Quinton R. Male hypogonadism and testosterone replacement. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 2022;97(3):295-306. (endocrinology.org)
Petersen M, et al. Testosterone misuse and counterfeit products in the online market. Clin Toxicol. 2019. (PMC)
Testosterone Treatment – AAFP. Am Fam Physician. 2017;96(7):441-449. (American Academy of Family Physicians)
Current National and International Guidelines for the Management of Male Hypogonadism. PMC. 2020. (PMC)
How Does Testosterone Impact Male Fertility? Progyny Education. 2024. (Progyny)
Liu P, et al. Age and Duration of Testosterone Therapy Predict Time to Return of Spermatogenesis. PMC. 2017; (Article). (PMC)
Recovery of Spermatogenesis Following Testosterone Replacement. PMC. 2014. (PMC)
The Optimal Indication for Testosterone Replacement Therapy in Late-Onset Hypogonadism. PMC. 2019. (PMC)
Current National and International Guidelines for the Management of Male Hypogonadism. PMC. 2020. (PMC)
